City of Hastings

County of Barry, State of Michigan

                                                                                                                                                                                                                               

 

CITY COUNCIL MINUTES

June 14, 2010

 

1.       Regular meeting called to order by Mayor May at 7:00 PM.

 

2.       Present at roll call were members: Bowers, Campbell, Depue, Jasperse, McNabb-Stange, Tossava, Tubbs, Wood, and May.

 

          City staff and appointees present: Mansfield, Emery, Sarver, Caris, Girrbach, Holzwarth, Timmerman, and Fekkes.

         

3.       Pledge to the flag.

 

4.       Approval of the agenda.

         

          Motion by Wood, with support by Tubbs, to add Item 8.D., Red Cross request to hold Blood Drive in parking lot #4, and Item 8.E., Request for acceptance of donation of funds for the purchase of “Summer Solstice” by Richard and Donna Tobias, and to approve the Agenda as amended.

          All ayes.  Motion carried.

         

5.       Approval of the minutes of the regular and closed session meetings of May 24, 2010 and the special workshop meeting of May 27, 2010.

 

Motion by Bowers, with support by Wood, to approve the regular and closed session minutes of May 24, 2010 as presented and to correct the special workshop minutes of May 27, 2010 to show Member Depue was not present and to approve the minutes as corrected.

          All ayes.  Motion carried.

 

6.       Proclamations: (None).

 

7.       Public Hearings:

 

A.       A public hearing to hear comment and make a determination on the operating budget for 2010/2011 and the millage rate to support that budget.

 

          Public hearing opened at 7:04 PM.

          No public comment.

          Public hearing closed at 7:05 PM.

 

          Consider Resolution 2010-16 to adopt the general appropriations act and set the millage rate for fiscal year 2010/2011.

 

          Campbell asked for amount of millage. Emery answered 16.0174 mills. Campbell asked why banking approvals are done in January. Fekkes responded.

Tossava regretted loss of Code Enforcement position.

 

Motion by McNabb-Stange, with support by Jasperse, to adopt Resolution 2010-16 as presented.

 

Ayes:            Bowers, Campbell, Depue, Jasperse, McNabb-Stange, Tossava, Tubbs, Wood, and May.

Nays:            None.

Absent:         None.

Motion carried.

 

B.       A public hearing to hear comment and make a determination on the final assessment roll for the 2010 downtown parking special assessment district.

 

          Public hearing opened at 7:08 PM.

          No public comment.

          Public hearing closed at 7:08 PM.

 

          Campbell stated that cost should be DDA’s responsibility.

 

          Consider Resolution 2010-17 to approve the final roll.

 

          Motion by Tubbs, with support by Wood, to adopt Resolution 2010-17 as presented.

 

          Ayes:            Bowers, Depue, Jasperse, McNabb-Stange, Tubbs, Wood, and May.

          Nays:            Campbell and Tossava.

          Absent:         None.

          Motion carried.

 

8.       Formal presentations and requests:

 

          A.       Request from Michael Bremer, candidate for 87th District seat of State House of Representatives, to introduce himself.

 

                   Mr. Bremer was not present.

 

          B.       Request from Megan Lavell, Executive Director of Thornapple Arts Council, for the Hastings City Band to use Fish Hatchery Park for its concert series.

 

Motion by Wood, with support by Bowers, to approve request under direction of City staff.

 

Ayes:            Bowers, Campbell, Depue, Jasperse, McNabb-Stange, Tossava, Tubbs, Wood, and May.

Nays:            None.

Absent:         None.

Motion carried.

 

C.                 Request from Michael L. Barnaart, President of Walldorff Brewpub & Bistro, to allow street closure for their anniversary celebration. Consider Resolution 2010-18 to stay the necessary ordinances.

 

Motion by Wood, with support by Bowers, to approve request under direction of City staff and adopt Resolution 2010-18 as presented.

 

                   Ayes:            Bowers, Campbell, Depue, Jasperse, McNabb-Stange, Tossava, Tubbs, Wood, and May.

                   Nays:            None.

                   Absent:         None.

                   Motion carried.

 

          D.       Request from Mark Englerth on behalf of the Red Cross to hold a blood drive in Parking Lot #4.

 

                   Motion by Wood, with support by McNabb-Stange, to approve request under direction of City staff.

 

                   Ayes:            Bowers, Campbell, Depue, Jasperse, McNabb-Stange, Tossava, Tubbs, Wood, and May.

                   Nays:            None.

                   Absent:         None.

                   Motion carried.

 

          E.       Request from Richard and Donna Tobias to donate funds to purchase “Summer Solstice”

                   as a gift to the City.

 

                   Motion by Wood, with support by Tubbs, to accept gift with appreciation.

 

                   Ayes:            Bowers, Campbell, Depue, Jasperse, McNabb-Stange, Tossava, Tubbs, Wood, and May.

                   Nays:            None.

                   Absent:         None.

                   Motion carried.

 

9.       Recommendations from other Boards: (None).

 

10.     Ordinances: (None).

 

11.     Resolutions: (None).

                  

12.     Appointments: (None).

 

13.     Bids, Contracts, Agreements, and Sales:

 

          A.       Consider purchase of a Handheld Data Collector, accessories, and training in the amount

                   of $16,980 as recommended by City Manager Mansfield.

         

                   Mansfield discussed.

                   Wood asked about converting City residential. Mansfield responded about previous investigation and high cost.

                   McNabb-Stange asked for detail of $16,980 total.  Mansfield responded about what was included and reminded Council that the township paid the system improvement fee to support such costs.

 

                   Motion by Tossava, with support by Wood, to approve purchase as recommended.

 

                   Ayes:            Bowers, Campbell, Depue, Jasperse, McNabb-Stange, Tossava, Tubbs, Wood, and May.

                    Nays:            None.

                   Absent:         None.

                   Motion carried.

 

          B.       Consider approval and authorization for the Mayor and Clerk to sign a service contract

                   with Green Gables Haven.

 

                   Motion by Jasperse, with support by Tossava, to approve and authorize the Mayor and

                    Clerk to sign the service contract as presented.

 

                   Ayes:            Bowers, Campbell, Depue, Jasperse, McNabb-Stange, Tossava, Tubbs, Wood, and May.

                   Nays:            None.

                   Absent:         None.

                   Motion carried.

 

          C.       Consider approval and authorization for the Mayor and Clerk to sign City Recreation

                   Agreement with YMCA of Barry County.

 

                   Motion by Tubbs, with support by Wood, to approve and authorize the Mayor and

                   Clerk to sign the agreement as presented.

 

                   Ayes:            Bowers, Campbell, Depue, Jasperse, McNabb-Stange, Tossava, Tubbs, Wood, and May.

                   Nays:            None.

                   Absent:         None.

                   Motion carried.

 

          D.       Consider approval and authorization for the Mayor and Clerk to sign a service contract

                   with Tom Thompson and Glenn Stoneburner, Professional Code Inspectors, to perform

                   Construction Code Administration and Enforcement and Rental Inspections.

 

                   Motion by Wood, with support by Tossava, to approve and authorize the Mayor and

                   Clerk to sign the service contract as presented.

 

                   Ayes:            Bowers, Campbell, Depue, Jasperse, McNabb-Stange, Tossava, Tubbs, Wood, and May.

                   Nays:            None.

                   Absent:         None.

                   Motion carried.

          E.       Consider approval and authorization for the Mayor and Clerk to sign MDOT Contract No.

                   10-4030, amending MDOT Contract 08-8069, regarding interest cost on the Michigan

                   Jobs Today Loan for the Sidewalk Project.

 

                   Motion by McNabb-Stange, with support by Wood, to approve and authorize the Mayor

                   and Clerk to sign the contract as presented.

 

                   Campbell stated that he opposed the special assessment levied in support of this project.

 

                   Ayes:            Bowers, Depue, Jasperse, McNabb-Stange, Tossava, Tubbs, Wood, and May.

                   Nays:            Campbell.

                   Absent:         None.

                   Motion carried.

 

          F.       Consider award of bid to Hallifax Services for Parks- Lawn Mowing and Maintenance for

                   the amount of $650/wk for a 3-year contract for a total of $18,200/28 weeks per year as

                   recommended by Director of Public Services Girrbach.

 

                   Motion by Bowers, with support by McNabb-Stange, to award bid as recommended.

 

                   Ayes:            Bowers, Campbell, Depue, Jasperse, McNabb-Stange, Tossava, Tubbs, Wood, and May.

                   Nays:            None.

                   Absent:         None.

                   Motion carried.

 

          G.                Consider award of bid to Hallifax Services for Parking Lots-Lawn Mowing and Maintenance for the amount of $100/wk for a 3 year contract for a total of $2,800/28 weeks per year as recommended by Director of Public Services Girrbach.

 

                    Motion by Bowers, with support by McNabb-Stange, to award bid as recommended.

 

                   Ayes:            Bowers, Campbell, Depue, Jasperse, McNabb-Stange, Tossava, Tubbs, Wood, and May.

                   Nays:            None.

                   Absent:         None.

                   Motion carried.

 

          H.       Consider award of bid to US Pavement Consultants for 2010/2011 Hot Mix Asphalt

                   Paving-Hand Patching in the amount of $100/Ton for Top Course and $100/Ton for Base Course for an estimated total of $20,000 as recommended by Director of Public Services Girrbach.

 

                   Motion by Wood, with support by McNabb-Stange, to award bid on a unit price basis as recommended.

 

                   Ayes:            Bowers, Campbell, Depue, Jasperse, McNabb-Stange, Tubbs, Wood, and May.

                   Nays:            Tossava.

                   Absent:         None.

                   Motion carried.

 

          I.                 Consider award of bid to Slagel Construction, Inc. for 2010/2011 Sidewalk and Curb and Gutter Replacement under Option #3 ($4.25/sqft 4” concrete, $4.70/sqft 6” concrete, $14.35/lnft curb & gutter) as recommended by Director of Public Services Girrbach.

 

                   Motion by Tubbs, with support by Tossava, to award bid on a unit price basis as

                   recommended.

 

                   Ayes:            Bowers, Campbell, Depue, Jasperse, McNabb-Stange, Tossava, Tubbs, Wood, and May.

                   Nays:            None.

                   Absent:         None.

                   Motion carried.

 

          J.                 Consider award of bid to Hometown Tree Service for 2010/2011 Tree Trimming and Tree Removal in the amount of $190/Removal and $75/Trim with the amount not to exceed $22,625 as recommended by Director of Public Services Girrbach.

 

                   Motion by McNabb-Stange, with support by Wood, to award bid as recommended.

 

                   Ayes:            Bowers, Campbell, Depue, Jasperse, McNabb-Stange, Tossava, Tubbs, Wood, and May.

                   Nays:            None.

                   Absent:         None.

                   Motion carried.

 

          K.                Consider award of bid to Haviland Products, Co. for Hydrofluosilicic Acid (HFS) in the amount of $78.00/150# Cylinder for an estimated total of $5,740 as recommended by Director of Public Services Tim Girrbach.

 

                   Motion by Tossava, with support by Wood, to award bid as recommended.

 

                   Ayes:            Bowers, Campbell, Depue, Jasperse, McNabb-Stange, Tossava, Tubbs, Wood, and May.

                   Nays:            None.

                   Absent:         None.

                   Motion carried.

                  

          L.       Consider award of bid to Superior Asphalt, Inc. for Hubble/East/Eaton Water Main Project Asphalt Paving, in the amount of $57.50/ton for Top Course and $57.59/Ton for Base Course for an estimated total of $20,125 as recommended by Director of Public Services Tim Girrbach.

 

                   Motion by Wood, with support by Tubbs, to award bid on a unit price basis as

                   recommended.

 

                   Ayes:            Bowers, Campbell, Depue, Jasperse, McNabb-Stange, Tossava, Tubbs, Wood, and May.

                   Nays:            None.

                   Absent:         None.

                   Motion carried.

 

          M.                Consider award of bid to WaterSolve, LLC for Polymer in the amount of $1.62/lb for an estimated total of $37,260 as recommended by Director of Public Services Tim Girrbach.

 

                   Motion by Wood, with support by McNabb-Stange, to award bid as recommended.

 

                   Ayes:            Bowers, Campbell, Depue, Jasperse, McNabb-Stange, Tossava, Tubbs, Wood, and May.

                   Nays:            None.

                   Absent:         None.

                   Motion carried.

 

          N.       Consider award of bid to Elhorn Company for Phosphate Poly/Ortho Blend in the amount of $13.00/gallon for an estimated total of $32,500 as recommended by Director of Public Services Tim Girrbach.

 

                   Motion by Wood, with support by Tubbs, to award bid as recommended.

 

                   Ayes:            Bowers, Campbell, Depue, Jasperse, McNabb-Stange, Tossava, Tubbs, Wood, and May.

                   Nays:            None.

                   Absent:         None.

                   Motion carried.

 

                             O.      Consider award of bid to USALCO for Liquid Aluminum Sulfate Hydrate Solution in the amount of $1.19/gallon for an estimated total of $41,650 as recommended by Director of Public Services Tim Girrbach.

                                     

                   Motion by Wood, with support by Tossava, to award bid as recommended.

 

                   Ayes:            Bowers, Campbell, Depue, Jasperse, McNabb-Stange, Tossava, Tubbs, Wood, and May.

                   Nays:            None.

                   Absent:         None.

                   Motion carried.

 

                             P.       Consider allowing Hoffman Manufacturing to repair two Hoffman Centrifugal Blowers at the Waste Water Treatment Plant in the amount of $33,369 and to make repairs to the third with an estimated cost of $15,000 as recommended by Director of Public Services Tim Girrbach.

 

                   Motion by Campbell, with support by Tossava, to make necessary repairs to the blowers

                   as recommended.

 

                   Ayes:            Bowers, Campbell, Depue, Jasperse, McNabb-Stange, Tossava, Tubbs, Wood, and May.

                   Nays:            None.

                   Absent:         None.

                   Motion carried.

 

14.     Consent items without individual discussion:

 

A.       Invoices.

                             Barry County Treasurer - $12,066.35

                             Lumec - $5,648.00 (DDA)

                             Michigan Municipal League - $9,459.00

B.                 Minutes of the Hastings Public Library Board of Directors meeting of May 17, 2010.

C.                 Letter from the Thornapple Arts Council thanking the City for support.

D.                 Minutes of the Cable Access Committee meeting of May 17, 2010.

E.                  Minutes of the Barry County Board of Commissioners meeting of May 25, 2010.

F.                  MML Legislative Link dated June 1, 2010.

G.                 MML Legislative Link dated June 8, 2010.

H.                 Communication regarding LDFA/BRA meeting on June 16, 2010.

I.                   Minutes of the Planning Commission meeting of June 7, 2010.

J.                   Minutes of the DDA meeting of May 20, 2010.

K.                 Michigan Advantage Newsletter.

 

          Motion by Wood, with support by McNabb-Stange, to receive items 14.A. through 14.K. inclusive and place on file.

          All ayes.  Motion carried.

 

15.     City Manager's report:

 

          A.       Director of Public Services Tim Girrbach gave his monthly report.

 

          B.       Fire Chief Roger Caris gave his monthly report.

 

          C.       Library Administrator Evelyn Holzwarth gave her monthly report.

 

16.     City Attorney's Report: (None).

 

17.     Legislative Director's Report:

 

Tubbs attended Mayor Exchange at Adrian and MML Region 2 meeting in Quincy. Adrian’s focus was on parking. Region2 was a census presentation.

 

18.     Open Public Discussion from the Floor:

 

          Rodney Collins attended for Boy Scouts Troop 175 to earn his Communication merit badge.

 

19.     Mayor and Council comment:

 

          Wood noted concern with recycling expressed by township and out-of-county residents.

          Campbell noted it was Flag Day today.

20.     Consider Closed Session as permitted by PA 267 of 1976, Section 15.268-8(c) for the strategy and negotiation sessions connected with the negotiation of a collective bargaining agreement.

 

Motion by Wood, with support by McNabb-Stange, to enter into closed session at 8:12 PM as permitted.

 

Ayes:            Bowers, Campbell, Depue, Jasperse, McNabb-Stange, Tossava, Tubbs, Wood, and May.

          Nays:            None.

          Absent:         None.

          Motion carried.

 

Return to open session at 9:20 PM.

 

21.     Motion by Wood to adjourn at 9:20 PM.

 

22.     Read and Approved:

 

 

 

                                                                                                                  

          Robert L. May, Mayor                                                Thomas E. Emery, City Clerk